About the Play




Introducing To Be Honest, from the writers



During the summer of 2016, we embarked on a project to learn how San Antonians were talking about Islam during the Presidential election. To Be Honest presents some of the provocative issues and charismatic characters from that work.


The idea for the research originated in 2015, when then-Presidential candidate Donald Trump announced that he would implement a ‘Muslim Ban’ if elected, advocating for a block on foreign Muslims coming into the United States as a way to combat terrorism. Months of intensive media coverage followed, moving the religion of Islam into the center of the 2016 Presidential campaign. We aimed to capture how people across religious, socioeconomic, and political divides made sense of this historical moment.


We wanted to reach as many people as possible, so with the aid of a Mellon Foundation Grant, we recruited undergraduate students Hana Niner (‘17), Iris Baughman (‘17) Savannah Wagner (‘17) and Matthew Long (‘19) to help. During an intensive 10-week long summer research institute, we read scholarly research about Islam, the media, and the rise of anti-Muslim sentiment in American politics. Dr. Kaufman trained the students to conduct qualitative, semi-structured interviews, and we all worked to craft the interview questions. We then reached out to religious and civic organizations across the political spectrum, and eventually interviewed 172 people one-on-one and in small focus groups. These were a truly diverse array of San Antonians, including people associated with local universities, churches, mosques, synagogues, the military, and a pagan meeting group.


Interviews lasted between 30 minutes and 2 hours, and by the end of the summer, we had over 200 hours of material recorded and transcribed. To be Honest shares just over an hour excerpted from these conversations, a very small portion. We have changed all names and recognizable details to protect our interviewees’ identities.


The main questions we asked are deceivingly simple - (as the students will tell you, we spent many hours debating the fine points) - but they were meant to provoke complex answers. We asked: In the Presidential campaign there has been a lot said about Islam; what have you heard? Does this remind you of any other time in history? How have you formulated your ideas about Islam? And: Have you experienced fear around these issues? As you watch the play, you may notice dialogue that refers back to these questions.


We did not begin this project with the intention to write a play. Like all good scholars, we anticipated academic publications. But the interviewees’ depth of engagement, vulnerabilities, hesitations, and honesty moved us, and we came to realize that their views would resonate with others. While they were speaking to us, we could not help but hear them as if they were speaking to each other. Our script for that reason is at once verbatim and fantasy. The interviewees gave us their words, but the juxtapositions of their stories are our own inventions.



William Christ, Sarah Beth Kaufman, and Habiba Noor


icrophone-PNG-Image.png

Comments